My colleague Todd Buras has inspired this argument:
- A veridical experience of an event is caused by the event.
- Sometimes a human being is veridically experiencing that she has some experience E at all the times at which E is occurring.
- If (1) and (2), then there is intra-mental simultaneous event causation.
- If naturalism about the human mind is true, there is no intra-mental simultaneous causation.
- So, naturalism about the human mind is not true.